Three ways to assess your quality maturity
Quality management system maturity matters—especially when it comes to your quality processes and systems.
Maturity matters—especially when it comes to your quality processes and systems
Quality maturity plays a key role in both the FDA Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER) Pharmaceutical Quality for the 21st Century initiative and the Center for Device and Radiological Health (CDRH) Case for Quality initiative. But how can a quality system be assessed for maturity?
Here’s what we’ve discovered.
What does “Mature” look like?
The overall maturity of your quality system depends on the maturity in each of three operational layers:
- Quality control
- Quality assurance
- Quality management
In a mature quality system, each layer has clear, well-defined processes and responsibilities. Information and data move between layers in a rational, predetermined way, triggering cascading evaluations and actions.
However, maturity in one layer can mask signs of trouble in another. Knowing which red flags indicate immaturity at each level can help you pinpoint and correct such problems.
Qualiy control maturity
Quality control describes the steps that are taken to make sure that only product that complies with the approved/accepted specifications is released for subsequent use or processing. In a mature quality control program, you can:
- Consistently identify product that is nonconforming or out of spec.
- Quickly escalate captured quality data to quality assurance decision-makers
- Accurately determine both root cause and necessary corrective actions
- Identify any issues with equipment before they affect product quality
Warning signs of an immature quality control program include:
- Failure to identify product quality issues before market impact
- Inconsistent classification of product quality issues
- Significant equipment failures that harm product quality and escape detection
An unusual or unexpected distribution of complaints across batches, ranges or sites can indicate problems with process variation or process control. By comparing the Standard Deviation and Mean of Complaints per Batch for a product, insight into the suitability of process and product control can be ascertained.
For example, the Standard Deviation being greater than the Mean would indicate some batches having complaint counts potential two, three, even 10 times the complaints count for other batches. That sort of complaint-by-batch distribution would suggest failure to identify nonconforming product prior to release —a sign of immature quality control—or allowing nonconforming product to be released—a hallmark of immature quality assurance.
Quality assurance maturity
Quality assurance not only supports and enables production operations but also handles and responds to quality control escalations. In a mature quality assurance program,
- Quality control issues are consistently addressed within risk classes.
- Reportable product quality issues are identified and promptly escalated, as needed.
- Quality control escalation is reported to the appropriate agency in a timely fashion.
- Investigations result in determination of a true root cause and actionable corrections.
Immature quality assurance results in less-than-thorough investigations and misidentification of both root cause and appropriate corrections. Product quality issues result in variable outcomes and are under-reported to the responsible agency.
To identify an immature quality assurance system, watch out for the following:
- Over-classification of records, which can suppress the identification of trends and relationships, leading to ineffective CAPA or repeating product quality issues.
- High rates of root causes related to “human” causes – User operator training, procedure incorrect or not followed and similar root cause categories may indicate inadequate training that doesn’t differentiate between qualified and unqualified personnel and doesn’t prevent unqualified personnel from handling product or making decisions.
- Frequent revision of procedures and other documents, which may suggest trial-and-error “development” of SOP, test methods, batch processing instructions and other reference documents.
- Rapid onboarding of new hires, with irregular training completion and per-day SOP read rates.
- Large volumes of Planned Deviations, a greater than expected ratio of processes with planned deviation (or temporary change control) compared to processes without planned deviation.
Quality management maturity
Quality management ensures that adequate resources are available for the production and control of quality product. Immaturity in quality control or assurance automatically indicates immature quality management, which is responsible for:
- Corporate compliance with regulatory requirements
- Enforcement of regulatory and internal requirements
- Directing operational decision-making and a corporate culture of quality
Aside from signs of immaturity in quality control or assurance, how can you identify immature quality management?
- High rates of SCAR/SCAPA and for-cause audits and a low rate of supplier disqualification, indicating ongoing use of poor suppliers and introducing risk into the quality of materials components received and placing more strain on quality control.
- High variable rates of deviation, OOS, or complaints without coordinated corrective actions to improve enable substandard processes (both manufacturing and supportive)
- Slow or absent reaction to quality issues that warrant reporting and market action
About the author
Daniel Burns is a Director of Product Management. Dan brings a wide breadth of industry experience coupled with practical knowledge as an end user of TrackWise and TrackWise Digital. He is very knowledgeable of the current FDA, EMEA and Health Canada regulations regarding manufacturing operations, packaging operations, quality control, R&D, warehouse management and distribution practices.
Recommended for you
-
QMS for Life Sciences - Quality Management
-
QMS Software Patient Safety
-
5 ways technology meets the challenges of complaint handling
-
Quality by Design Article
-
Shaping the Future of Quality RQA
-
Unveiling the Hidden Costs of Recalls in the Life Sciences Industry
-
Sparta Systems and Quartic AI Announce Partnership to Connect Qms to Manufacturing Operations
-
Unlock the Secrets to Streamlined Risk Assessments and Process Improvements
-
ABF-Pharmazie’s Journey with TrackWise Quality Document and Training Management
-
Quality Management New Product
-
Gaining Assurance: A Quality Move
-
Melinda Novatny Integra life Sciences
-
The Evolution of Pharma MES
-
Integrated Risk Management Benefits
-
Get ready for the new european medical device regulation
-
Perform Effective Root Cause Analysis
-
Improving Manufacturing Performance – Moving Beyond OEE to Operational Intelligence
-
What the EU MDR Delay Due to the Coronavirus Pandemic Means for You
-
Alleviate supply chain pressure in the face of a pandemic
-
Root Cause Essentials Continuous Improvement
-
Digital QMS Life Sciences
-
How to build a business case for AI-powered quality
-
How to Choose the Right MES or Manufacturing Operations Platform
-
3 Ways the CAPA Process is Like Preparing for the Big Game
-
Simplify And Standardize the Power of Quality Process Accelerators
-
Virtual Sparta Connection 2020
-
CAPA Management: Technology to the Rescue
-
Legacy Quality Management Systems
-
How to establish supplier qualifications session
-
Honeywell Technologies named a leader in 2026 Quality Management System Technology Value Matrix
-
Prevent Quality Failures: The Power of a QMS
-
Managing Quality Within the Medical Device Supply Chain
-
Remote Supplier Audits
-
Five quality processes AI is transforming in Life Sciences
-
Quality Data Business Technology
-
How to build a business case for QMS investment
-
The Role of QMS During a Global Health Crisis
-
Artificial Intelligence (AI) in life sciences quality management: evolution, impact, and future
-
The Key To Moving Beyond Compliance In 2019
-
Voice Of Customer Sheetal Mane Piramal
-
The Benefits of Integrating Enterprise Quality Management
-
Insud Pharma’s Journey with TrackWise Digital: Transforming Global Quality Management
-
Philips Healthcare Quality Transformation with Trackwise
-
Shawn McKinley Senior Analyst Information Systems Cambrex
-
QMS - Effective Implementation of a Quality Management System
-
How to successfully transition to a cloud QMS
-
3 Types of Batch Technologies to Maximize Productivity and Profitability
-
Quality vs Compliance
-
Prioritizing a Stronger OT Cybersecurity Posture in Life Sciences Organizations
-
Root Cause Essentials Unleash the Power of Your Mind with Mind Mapping
-
3 Benefits of a Cloud-Based Quality Management System
-
Supplier Management Experts
-
Measure What Matters
-
Proactive quality and the bimodal challenge for life science manufacturers
-
How predictive quality is transforming Life Sciences
-
Honeywell Enables Transformation of Life Sciences Manufacturing and Quality Management with TrackWise® Life Sciences Platform
-
Reducing Total Cost of Ownership with an Integrated Pharma Manufacturing Platform
-
Post Market Surveillance Udi Compliance for Class I Devices Moves Forward with New Deadline
-
Why connected data is the foundation for AI in quality management
-
An overview of AI in key quality management processes
-
Expansion Of The Data Integrity Body Of Knowledge
-
A practical roadmap to connected quality in Life Sciences
-
QMS - How Does a QMS Work? Understanding the Core Principles and Functionality
-
7 Must-have quality KPIs
-
Document Management: Communication with Regulators
-
Take the fear out of change with an automated change management process
-
Quality Challenges Facing the Medical Device Industry
-
Document Management Systems: Risks and Solutions
-
Quality Management as a Strategic Technology Partner
-
Digital Audit Management Software
-
QMSR Medical Devices
-
Flipping CAPA on its Head with Prevention and Understanding the True Root Cause
-
Trackwise Digital Video Testimonial From Celonic
-
5 functions that elevate your QMS
-
QMS - Exploring the Key Components of a Quality Management System
-
Why Is a QMS Important
-
Sparta Experts RQA 2021
-
How to meet changing objectives update your quality plan
-
Where Are You on the Quality Management Maturity Spectrum
-
Life Sciences Quality Trends
-
ISO 9001 QMS
-
Integrated Document Management: Leveraging Technology
-
The Patient Centric Passion Behind Sparta Meet Dr Oxana K Pickeral pH D MBA President and CEO of Sparta Systems
-
Why faster decisions have become a competitive advantage in life sciences manufacturing
-
Sparta Systems User Groups
-
Paving the Way to Proactive Quality Tips for a Successful Journey
-
Medical Device Supplier Quality
-
Hidden costs of disconnected quality systems in Life Sciences
-
Five common misconceptions about Quality 4.0
-
The Quality 4.0 Productivity Paradox
-
Voice of Customer Rahul Songire Senior General Manager Cqa Digital Transformation Journey With Trackwise Qms
-
Trackwise Digital Document Control Software
-
Three ways to assess your quality maturity
-
Finalized: EU Publishes GMP Annex 1 Revision
-
Digital CAPA Management Software
-
Quality Best Practices Council
-
From Data to Knowledge: Building Workforce Intelligence in Pharma Manufacturing
-
Document Management a Tale of Two Manufacturers
-
QMS - The Elements of a Successful CAPA Process
-
Olympus Quality Transformation Journey
-
Qms Software Supply Chain
-
Gamp-5-second-edition
-
Voice Of Customer Suruchi Sharma Abbott
-
The Honeywell Life Sciences Applications Suite Leverages the Power of AWS Cloud to Accelerate Innovation
-
Selecting the Right QMS
-
What is MES in pharma manufacturing? A practical guide
-
Digital QMS Value
-
Voice Of Customer Srinivas Hosadurga Cipla TrackWise
-
Uncovering The Root Cause And Overcoming Challenges Along The Way
-
Mastering Modern Recall Management a 6 Part Journey to Excellence
-
Is your quality management decision-making impaired by unreliable data?
-
Strike the right balance between compliance and quality
-
QMS - Unlocking the value: Benefits of implementing a quality management system (QMS)
-
Three Reasons to Take Your Document Management Digital
-
The Power of Integration a Holistic Approach To Quality and Document Management
-
QMS Change Management During the Time of Coronavirus
-
TrackWise Digital Success Series
-
Protect Your Product from the Risks of Supply Chain Complexity
-
Reflecting on World Quality Week
-
DMS Integrated Quality Management
-
Measuring the Success of a QMS
-
Accelerating time-to-market in life sciences manufacturing
-
6 Signs of a flawed risk management process
-
Revolutionizing Quality Management Review From Compliance Task to Strategic Insight
-
Proactive Quality Management in 2020
-
The Elements of a Successful CAPA Process
-
Manufacturing Excellence Platform: An Advanced MES Solution
-
Pharmaceutical Quality Digital QMS
-
How Industry 4.0 is Revolutionizing Life Sciences Workforce Solutions
-
3 Ways Digitalization Can Improve Operational Efficiency in Life Sciences Manufacturing
-
4 Strategies to Transform Life Sciences Manufacturing Workforce
-
Five Reasons OT Cybersecurity Must be an Immediate Priority in Life Sciences
-
5 Ways Technology is Rewriting the Workforce Playbook in Life Sciences
-
Hidden Quality Costs in Life Sciences Manufacturing | Honeywell Technologies